Community Divided Over Low-Barrier Shelter Plans Amid Rising Homelessness in Kansas City

Community Split on New Shelter Plans as Homelessness Rises in Kansas City

Kansas City is grappling with the challenges of homelessness as local leaders continue to rethink the strategy for providing shelter. Recently, residents in the Lykins neighborhood have voiced their opinions about the need for a low-barrier shelter—something that hasn’t materialized despite ongoing discussions and proposals over the years. With many people living unsheltered and encampments popping up in residential areas, local residents are starting to wonder if a shelter could actually improve the situation.

Shelter Supporters Speak Out

Lois Comstock, a friendly face in the Lykins neighborhood for over a decade, is among those who believe a shelter would be a positive change. She expressed, “I think a shelter would be so good. Somewhere around here would be nice.” Comstock’s enthusiasm surfaces amid troubling circumstances; she lives near numerous homeless encampments, including one that tragically experienced a homicide last month. The unfortunate incident involving 35-year-old Johnathan Rodgers, who died from blunt force trauma in an encampment nearby, highlighted the urgency behind discussions for a safer option. Local residents are now seeing the consequences of unregulated encampments—fires, sanitation concerns, and even crime.

The Wider Picture of Homelessness in Kansas City

According to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Kansas City has the highest percentage of chronically homeless individuals living unsheltered among major U.S. cities. Currently, a permanent low-barrier shelter—one that doesn’t require participation in specific programs—remains a goal for the city. Unfortunately, Kansas City lacks one, even as it’s been granted federal funds earmarked for such a facility. In the interim, a temporary winter shelter system is set to open its doors at multiple locations come December, yet it does not fill the need for a lasting solution.

Community Concerns and Resistance

Despite the evident need for a shelter, many locals express reservations about being “the ones left to shoulder the burden.” Community members have shared concerns at City Council meetings, emphasizing they acknowledge homelessness is an issue throughout the city but would prefer solutions that spread the responsibility more evenly. One resident remarked at a public commentary session, “Homelessness is everywhere. Services should be everywhere.” It’s a refrain heard often in the community, as many residents want to see more balanced decision-making.

Mixed Reactions About a Proposed Shelter

Not everyone is on board with the idea of a shelter. Carol Marquez, a neighbor who has witnessed escalating issues from the encampments—including gun violence and drug use—shared her views: “I want to live out my retirement in peace.” Marquez believes a shelter could prove to be a viable solution, yet she remains cautious. Others, like a man who asked to remain anonymous, expressed skepticism about whether a shelter would be effective, stating that those experiencing homelessness should focus on obtaining jobs. This sentiment highlights a deep divide in the community regarding how best to tackle these pressing issues.

Connecting the Community and Struggling Individuals

Angie Hicks-Curtis, who leads the Lykins Neighborhood Association, is working to bridge the gap between residents and those experiencing homelessness. She noted the ongoing challenges of insufficient affordable housing, stating, “There aren’t enough beds or affordable homes in the city.” Hicks-Curtis aims to help guide individuals living outside towards resources, something she hopes will lead to long-term solutions for everyone. While some conversations around possible shelter solutions may lean towards opposition, Hicks-Curtis remains optimistic about finding common ground.

A Path to Change?

As Kansas City continues to wrestle with the complex issues surrounding homelessness, it seems clear that more dialogue between community members and policymakers is critical. With advocates like Hicks-Curtis leading the charge, it may be possible to shift perspectives and encourage a supportive environment for everyone, both in and out of homes. As the winter season approaches, the call for meaningful solutions becomes even more pressing, and whether that means providing shelters, expanding services, or simply fostering understanding remains to be seen. For now, residents await the city’s next move.